I try not to go really low, when everything is blinking I'm heading to my preferred station. I have a preferred place, we all likely do, and I do my best to always fill up there and I know the quality of the fuel I get. If I need fuel out of town I try to find a Shell or Petrocan and neither has failed me. My 2017 is not a fan of Esso, Mobil, Gulf, Husky, or Pioneer. I've read the refineries produce the same product for all the retail stations but I have my doubts of that.
My Saturn prefers Shell, Esso, and a local place in Niagara with many outlets, full serve at self serve prices.