I took the Nokian snow tires off the front of my Mirage a couple weeks ago. That very night, we got our largest snow fall of the winter. Overall, we didn't get a lot of snow this winter. I've snow plowed with my ATV maybe 4 times.
Got to test out the newer Kumho Solus TA31 tires up front in some slushy wet snow the other day, & they struggled. The 5 year old Nokian snow tires are still better by a good amount.
If I didn't have an AWD vehicle with good snow tires parked in the garage, I wouldn't have pulled my winter tires off the front of my Mirage so soon. Any snow we get now seems gone in a day or two now. I am planning to pull the tire chains off my Mule today, & that may cause the next snow storm.